I've had these chalkboard Tic Tac Toe cookies on my mind for 9 months! I made the Tic-Tac-Toe board last May when I was cutting a square piece of sugar cookie dough with a tiny square cutter. I wasn't sure how or when I'd incorporate it into a cookie, until the theme turned Valentine's Day and the Xs and Os made perfect sense! Here are the 5 cookies in one jumbo Valentine cookie: 5"x3" rectangle, Tic-Tac-Toe board, 2 mini circles & 1 mini square.
The black icing will dry within about 20 minutes.
I adhered the Tic-Tac-Toe board cookie to the chalkboard cookie with a few dabs of vanilla frosting on the back of the cookie.
To get the chalk look, press the tip all the way to the cookie and let the frosting smear a bit.
More Valentine Cookies coming...
Want more Valentine's Day inspiration?
Click on Cupid.